Tag Archive for 'Seesmic'

用户不需要“视频评论”的五个理由

视讯网 4月26日消息 昨天在视讯网的文章里看到“Seesmic的Wordpress插件支持视频评论”,我个人认为,用户根本不需要“视频评论”功能,理由如下:

第一,“视频评论”无法快速阅读

我们知道,很多文章的评论只需要用户“扫描式”阅读即可,而视频在这方面的表现绝对不如文字。假如一篇文章有很多个评论,用户是不可能花太多的时间在视频评论上面的,因为如果一个文字评论你可以用10秒钟看完的话,那么视频评论你至少要用45秒钟才可以看完。

第二,垃圾评论很难鉴别

正因为“视频评论”无法快速扫描式阅读,所以每一个评论用户必须从头到尾全看完才能知道是不是垃圾评论,或者是广告、文不对题的无意义评论,这将浪费太多的时间;而且,对于网站管理员来说,垃圾评论的处理将是一个天大的难题。

第三,“视频评论”制作门槛高

这点不用多说,没有几个用户会为了一篇文章去专门制作一个“视频评论”,除非特殊情况,我相信大部分文章是没有这个必要的,更何况,制作“视频评论”并不是一个简单的事情。

第四,无法给“视频评论”加超链接

超链接的作用每个用户都知道,而“视频评论”在这方面却做不到!当然,你可以选择在“视频评论”里大声重复你的超链接网址,但你能想像的出阅读者当时的心情,简直糟透了。

第五,“视频评论”导致页面载入时间增长

如果你乐意等的话,可以留下来阅读“视频评论”,但我相信,没有几个用户会这么做。要知道,无论网站管理者使用什么样的播放插件,都将会增加页面的载入时间。

结论:

“视频评论”相对来说是一个新生事物,所以它今后的发展如何我们还很难下定论,毕竟“存在就是合理的”,有些情况下“视频评论”还是相当不错的应用,比如,某某名人或某某权威的“视频评论”,对用户来说还是相当有阅读诱惑力的。

这里有一份到目前为止(作者发稿时)的投票结果,投票还正在进行中:

Seesmic + Twhirl is a Vision of the Web’s Future

Loic Le Meur’s video chat service Seesmic is announcing tonight that it has acquired leading 3rd party Twitter client Twhirl. Seesmic is still in closed Alpha status right now - though we have invites if you’d like them: email marshall@readwriteweb.com with the word Seesmic in the subject line and we’ll send you one.

How could the acquisition of an app that runs entirely on the Twitter API, by another service that isn’t even publicly available yet be a big deal? Let us count the ways…

Seesmic gets Twhirl’s fast growing userbase, cross platform desktop AIR envrionment and its very capable developer. Marco Kaiser, creator of Twhirl, gets a job, presumably cash and stock in Seesmic, plus access to Seesmic’s high-profile funding and Loic Lemur’s catchet. It could have been Snitter or it could have been Twitterrific, but Twhirl has the momentum among 3rd party Twitter clients and that’s who moved first.

Twhirl even got on Fox News this week. They didn’t spell its name right, but the point is that Twitter is creeping into the mainstream and Twhirl is the best way to use Twitter.

Here’s Seesmic CEO Loic Le Meur talking about the deal, followed by our analysis of the technology implications.

XMPP

Seesmic runs on XMPP/Jabber, the protocol that provides the immediate communication and presence awareness of many Instant Messenging clients. You know how nice, smooth and in-touch IM is. Once any of your internet communication experiences goes on in that kind of environment - you don’t ever want to go back again. At the very least, it’s a game changing option to have along with asynchronous forms of communication.

Surprisingly, it’s the video half of this deal that supports XMPP now, not the Twitter half.

We wrote in January about XMPP powering the future of online communication. Twitter supports XMPP messenging but only native IM clients like Google Talk seem to have integrated it so far. Seesmic plus Twhirl, powered by XMPP is going to be hot. Instant text and video communication and presence status.

Video + Microblogging = Rich User Experience

The video experience of Seesmic is hard to explain until you’ve tried it. It’s a lot more than just “Twitter for video.” (See our post “Seesmic Transcends Comparisons With Twitter“) Those differences are going to soften now, though. A combined service will offer a continum of communication depending on your broadcasting comfort and time to consume inbound messages. Text is what the vast majority of people prefer to produce, but video is incredibly compelling to consume.

Lifestreaming

How long until even more services are rolled into this new dynamo? Seesmic already integrates outbound publishing with YouTube, Qik and Twitter. How long until the company rolls out lifestreaming capabilities ala FriendFeed, displaying recent user and aggregate-friend activity on any number of other services - then storming the Facebook Newsfeed as a packaged solution to the 3rd party RSS feed dilemma there? Probably not very long. FriendFeed is already inching towards the Newsfeed, literally, by getting into the Minifeed on Facebook. Every social network wants to act as the central location for user activity around the web, but it’s far less trivial than just letting users plug in RSS feeds or usernames. Lifestreaming apps are making this a service, FriendFeed is the leader today, but somehow this functionality is a logical thing to come to Seesmic/Twhirl next.

Seesmic won’t be able to work too closely with anything more than the recently launched FriendFeed API because that service, for all its nimbleness risks holding out for an unrealistically large acquisition more than it risks anything else.

There’s no shortage of lifestreaming apps that the company could work with, though.

AIR - Cross Platform RIA

The best thing about Twhirl is that it’s built in Adobe AIR. While Microsoft’s Silverlight is coming on hard and fast, the AIR/Flex/Flash ecosystem is made for hotness and has the most momentum in the grassroots developer community.

AIR lets developers write in HTML, Javascript and Flash - but run it on the desktop - of a Windows, Mac or Linux computer. These are Rich Internet Applications - apps that sit on the desktop and function outside the browser, but that are tied to the web and leverage connectivity as well. Check out Redmonk’s RIA Weekly Podcast if you want to get excited about RIAs on a regular basis.

The Future

The second multimedia communication service built on AIR that gets acquired is going to go for a much higher price than we can presume this first one did, especially if it comes into the deal with XMPP of its own. Throw in integration of the new UStream API for live streaming video and you’ve got the kind of platform that Skype could have become if it hadn’t hit the swamp of mega-acquisition. Twhirl and Seesmic together have many of the traits that countless other companies are looking for, now.

Seesmic plus Twhirl is of course just two very forward-looking organizations in a large, diverse economy of innovation. Look at this deal though and you’ll see a big part of the future of online communication technology, no matter who it is that makes it happen.